Ask the realtor — When your listing isn’t selling: Lower the price or buy down the rate?

May 21, 2025 | Ask the Realtor

Theresa Grant, Realtor Advice Column.

In today’s real estate market, where high interest rates have cooled buyer enthusiasm and affordability is top of mind, sellers facing sluggish showings or stalled offers are asking an important question: Should we lower the price – or use that same amount to help the buyer with a rate buy-down?

A price reduction might seem like the simplest path. After all, buyers searching online are often filtered by price brackets, and trimming the list price could attract new eyeballs. But what many sellers don’t realize is that even a significant drop in price – say, $25,000 – may not make a meaningful difference in a buyer’s monthly payment. In contrast, offering that same amount toward a mortgage interest rate buy-down can substantially improve a buyer’s purchasing power and monthly affordability, especially in the $500,000 to $1 million range.

Here’s how it works: When a seller offers a credit toward the buyer’s interest rate, the lender can “buy down” the rate, often by a full percentage point or more. That can lower the buyer’s monthly mortgage payment by hundreds of dollars, making your home more appealing without sacrificing perceived value. For many buyers, especially those watching every dollar, the monthly payment matters more than the purchase price.

This strategy is particularly effective when your home is competing with similarly priced listings, and buyers are comparing payments side-by-side. If your home stands out because it offers a more favorable payment, you’ve now widened your pool of eligible buyers—without automatically slashing your price.

It’s also worth noting that rate buy-downs can be marketed more effectively than a quiet price cut. “Seller offering interest rate buy-down!” on your marketing materials or in your online listing grabs attention and signals flexibility. Buyers who may have been priced out by current rates suddenly find your home back in their budget. That can revive interest and, in some cases, spark multiple offers.

Of course, this strategy works best in collaboration with your real estate agent and your buyer’s lender. Not all loan types allow for the same buy-down structure, and timing matters. If you’ve already done a price reduction and still haven’t seen movement, consider pivoting your approach before another drop.

In this market, the conversation is no longer just about price – it’s about monthly cost. As mortgage rates remain elevated, creative solutions like seller-paid rate buy-downs can make the difference between your home sitting or selling.

Before you chop the price again, talk to your agent about whether applying that same dollar amount toward helping your buyer afford the home makes better financial and strategic sense. The key to selling today isn’t just lowering the price. It’s increasing affordability.

If you’d like to learn more about the current local market conditions, reach out to Theresa Grant, Real Estate Broker (DRE #01202881), at Theresa@HomesInLakeArrowhead.com. You can also follow on social: Instagram, @theresagrantrealtor | YouTube: @theresagrantrealtor. Theresa is a Broker Associate with REAL Broker Technologies.

 

0 Comments

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Share

Business Directory

goodwin-web-ad
kw logo adopt a highway
Arrowhead Boat Yard
MCH-web-ad

READ SIMILAR ARTICLES